# How the rules are kept accurate

> How Checkbox's legal catalog is written and checked — primary sources, a full re-read at each review, tracking amendments, how to report an error, and the corrections log.

Every check Checkbox runs traces to a rule in its legal catalog, and every rule links to the text of the law it comes
from. This page explains how those rules are written and kept up to date. Checkbox is automated checks, not legal
advice; the [legal disclaimer](https://checkbox.site/docs/legal) says what that means.

## What a passing check does not mean {#limits}

Checkbox is compliance software, not a law firm. Its rules are written and maintained by the Checkbox team from the
text of each law; the date of the last full review against the sources is on the [laws page](https://checkbox.site/laws#maintainers), and
errors fixed since are in the [corrections log](https://checkbox.site/docs/corrections). Its results are automated checks, not legal advice.
Passing the checks does not guarantee that your program complies with the law. You remain solely responsible for your
subscription program, and Checkbox takes on no legal liability for it (see the [Terms](https://checkbox.site/terms)).

## Primary sources {#sources}

Each rule is written from the official text of the law: the state legislature's code or session laws, the U.S. Code,
the Federal Register and eCFR, or the city's rules. Law-firm trackers and guides are used only to find laws worth
reading, never as the source of a rule. Where only part of the official text could be read, the law says so on its
page ("enacted session-law text read; current codified text not retrieved" or "secondary sources only").

Each rule records its citation, a link to the source, the date it takes effect and the conditions under which it
applies, so you or your lawyer can check it against the law yourselves.

## How the checks are tested {#testing}

Every release is run against an accuracy set of nearly 1,000 cases (more than 1,300 labelled results): sign-up pages, Stripe Checkout and Payment Link settings, emails and cancellation flows in many layouts and wordings, each labelled with the result the law calls for. A release ships only with zero false passes on that set (a case that should not pass never passes), and every false pass a tester finds becomes a new case. More than 6,000 automated tests run alongside it. Don't rely on Checkbox for legal certainty: if you need a legal opinion, talk to a lawyer.

## A full re-read at each review {#review}

A full review reads every cataloged law again, in full, against its official source, and compares it with the rules
in the catalog: wording, effective dates, notice windows, who can sue and the remedies. The date of the last full review
is on every [law page](https://checkbox.site/laws) and in the [open dataset](https://checkbox.site/laws/data). Laws that were researched but deliberately not
turned into rules are listed with the reason.

## Tracking amendments {#amendments}

Each law keeps its history: the amendments that changed it, with their effective dates. A rule that has been
amended keeps its earlier version, so a past result can be traced to the rule that applied on that day. Rules that
are enacted but not yet in force carry their future effective date and start applying on that date.

Every catalog change gets a new catalog version. Each check result carries the `catalog_version` and `catalog_hash`
it was evaluated against, and changes are published in the [changelog](https://checkbox.site/changelog), the
[law updates](https://checkbox.site/docs/api/law-updates) feed and the `law.changed` webhook.

## Reporting an error {#report}

If you believe a rule, a law page or anything on checkbox.site is wrong, email
[support@checkbox.site](mailto:support@checkbox.site) with the page or rule id and what you believe is wrong (a link to
the source helps). We check each report against the official text; confirmed errors are fixed and listed in the
corrections log.

## The corrections log {#corrections}

Errors that were published and then fixed are listed, with the date and the catalog version that carries the fix, in
the [corrections log](https://checkbox.site/docs/corrections). New rules and clearer wording are in the [changelog](https://checkbox.site/changelog).
