# Corrections log

> Dated corrections to the law pages, the legal catalog and statements on checkbox.site — what was wrong, what it says now, and the catalog version that carries the fix.

When something Checkbox published turns out to be wrong, it is corrected and listed here with the date. To report an
error, email [support@checkbox.site](mailto:support@checkbox.site) with the page and what you believe is wrong. To
report a wrong check result, use **Report a wrong result** under the result in the dashboard, or have your agent call
`send_feedback` with `type: "wrong_verdict"` ([MCP](https://checkbox.site/docs/mcp)); a confirmed wrong result is listed here too. Every
catalog change, corrections included, is also in the [changelog](https://checkbox.site/changelog), the
[open dataset](https://checkbox.site/laws/data) and the [law updates](https://checkbox.site/docs/api/law-updates) feed.

Newest first. Only errors are listed here; new rules and clearer wording are in the changelogs.

**Effect on customers so far:** none of the corrections below changed whether a check passes or fails. Most fixed
wording on a page; one changed a setting: consent receipts can no longer be kept for less than 3 years (the lowest
setting was 30 days before Nov. 8, 2026).

## November 17, 2026 {#2026-11-17}

- **Acknowledgment-terms check: citation** (catalog `2026.11.17.1`). "Acknowledgment restates the automatic-renewal
  terms" cited 15 U.S.C. § 1693e(a) / 12 C.F.R. § 1005.10(b) (Regulation E) first, on the home page preview, the sample
  report and in check results. Regulation E asks for a copy of the authorization for recurring debits from a bank,
  debit or prepaid account and does not apply to credit-card billing; it does not ask that an acknowledgment restate the
  renewal terms. The check now cites the state acknowledgment rules that do, e.g. Cal. Bus. & Prof. Code § 17602(a)(3)
  and N.Y. Gen. Bus. Law § 527-a(1)(c). No check's result changed.

## November 10, 2026 {#2026-11-10}

- **New York City law page: material-change notice.** The summary said Checkbox schedules the notice "7-30 calendar
  days ahead". The rule asks for at least 5 business days, and Checkbox Notices already counts business days (skipping
  weekends and public holidays) for New York City as for New York State; the page now says so. The scope line also
  said "open question 9"; it now says in plain words that how far the rule reaches outside the city, and how it works
  alongside the Attorney General's enforcement of the state law, are not settled yet.
- **Home page: the passing checkout example.** The "after" checkout showed a line without "(plus applicable taxes)" and
  with "Cancel anytime in Account → Billing", which differed from the text the engine suggests and passes further down
  the page. It now shows that exact text.
- **/security.** The subhead said nobody, "not a compromised page", can quietly change the record. A compromised page
  can change what is captured next; the claim now covers the record once captured.
- **"What plaintiffs look for": Adobe and Shutterstock.** The guide said both had settled ("Adobe ($150M, 2026)",
  "Shutterstock ($35M, 2026)"), which read as final outcomes and did not match the [federal law page](https://checkbox.site/laws/federal).
  Both are proposed orders filed with the court (Adobe in March 2026, after the Justice Department's June 2024
  complaint; Shutterstock in May 2026, in an FTC case), and Checkbox has not confirmed that a court entered either one.
  The guide now says exactly that and links the government's own announcements.

## November 9, 2026 {#2026-11-09}

- **California law page: remedies** (catalog `2026.11.09.3`). The summary said "civil (UCL) remedies only (§ 17604)".
  § 17604 says a violation is not a crime and that all available civil remedies apply; in practice suits go through
  the UCL, FAL and CLRA. It now says exactly that.
- **Home page and sample report: the consent box.** They described "a box the customer ticks" as what the law asks
  for. The laws ask for a separate, affirmative yes to the renewal; an unticked box is the usual way to get it. The
  wording now says so.
- **/developers: Stripe test keys.** It said Checkbox accepts a `sk_test_` or `rk_test_` key. Full `sk_test_` keys are
  refused; only a restricted `rk_test_` key is accepted.
- **Snippet: "Other page text is not sent".** The snippet also sends the block just before and after each button, box,
  link and terms block, so a headline next to a sign-up button can be sent. /security and the snippet docs now say so
  and show a [sample payload](https://checkbox.site/docs/snippet#sample-payload).
- **Federal law page summary.** It said ROSCA and Regulation E are "the federal rules every US subscription business
  follows". ROSCA covers subscriptions sold online and Regulation E covers recurring debit-card and ACH payments, so it
  now says exactly that. The FTC Negative Option Rule (16 C.F.R. Part 425) entry showed only its 2026 recodification
  date and a confidence grade; it now reads "Originally effective 1973; recodified Feb. 12, 2026 (91 FR 6507)" and "In
  force for prenotification plans only; not checked by Checkbox".
- **Catalog version number.** The catalog published on Nov. 9 was numbered `2026.11.10.1`, a date that had not come
  yet. Catalog versions are named for the day they are published, so it is now `2026.11.09.2`. Its content did not
  change. Pages now say when the whole catalog was last reviewed against its sources (Oct. 29, 2026) and point here
  for corrections made since.
- **Federal law page: FTC click-to-cancel amendments** (catalog `2026.11.09.2`). The history row said the 2024
  amendments were both "effective" and "vacated before taking effect". Now: the rule took effect Jan. 14, 2025, most
  provisions had a July 14, 2025 compliance date, and the Eighth Circuit vacated the whole rule on July 8, 2025, before
  that compliance date. None of it is enforceable.
- **Federal law page title.** It named the FTC Act without an entry for it. The title now reads "ROSCA and Regulation
  E", and the page explains that the FTC Act is how ROSCA is enforced and where § 5 is cited.
- **Home page: "Read-only until you approve a change".** The one Stripe key Checkbox asks for has Write permissions
  (used for fixes you approve and for test runs in test mode), so "read-only" was not accurate. It now says "Changes
  nothing until you approve", and the [Stripe key guide](https://checkbox.site/docs/guides/stripe-key) groups each permission by when it is
  used.
- **Privacy Policy: Elements consent records.** It said these are kept for the customer's records period. They are kept
  for at least that period and never less than the California floor that also applies to consent receipts (at least 3
  years, or 1 year after the subscription ends if later).
- **California fee-change notices** (catalog `2026.11.09.1`). Material changes that are fee changes were shown as sent
  60 days ahead, which § 17602(g)(2)'s 7–30 day window does not allow. Notices now sends them 28 days before.
- **Adobe** (catalog `2026.11.09.1`) is described as a Justice Department complaint filed June 2024; no entered order
  is cited.

## November 8, 2026 {#2026-11-08}

- **FTC click-to-cancel amendments** (catalog `2026.11.08.5`). A note said they "never took effect"; it now says they
  were vacated on July 8, 2025.
- **New York civil penalties** (catalog `2026.11.08.3`). The remedies row said GBL § 527-a names no civil penalty. That
  was wrong: § 527-a(3) sets civil penalties in Attorney General actions.
- **Delaware** (catalog `2026.11.08.2`). The statute gives no treble damages; exposure moved from "private right,
  treble" to "via general consumer law" (6 Del. C. § 2525).
- **Alaska** (catalog `2026.11.08.1`). The provision is AS 45.50.471(b)(49), not (b)(47).

These four were also made on Nov. 8 and added to this log on Nov. 10, 2026:

- **Consent receipt retention** (/trust, /privacy, /terms, /security). These pages said consent receipts could be kept
  for as little as 30 days, and said nothing about the end of the subscription. California requires proof of consent to
  be kept at least 3 years, or 1 year after the contract ends if that is longer (Cal. Bus. & Prof. Code
  § 17602(a)(6)). The minimum is now 3 years, receipts are kept until 1 year after the subscription ends when that is
  later, and all four pages state the same rule.
- **California law page: notice windows and record period** (catalog `2026.11.08.5`). The summary read "trial (> 31
  days, 3-21 days) and 1-year-term (15-45 days) notices" and "consent records kept 3 years". It now says what each
  notice is for: one 3-21 days before a free trial or promotional price lasting more than 31 days ends, and one 15-45
  days before a term of one year or longer renews; and consent records are kept 3 years, or 1 year after termination if
  longer.
- **Federal law page: private right of action** (catalog `2026.11.08.5`). The at-a-glance row said only "No: ROSCA is
  enforced by the FTC and state attorneys general", which left out Regulation E. It now names each law: ROSCA gives no
  private right (FTC and state attorneys general enforce it, 15 U.S.C. §§ 8404-8405); the Electronic Fund Transfer Act
  does (15 U.S.C. § 1693m).
- **/about: which products use Checkbox.** The heading "We use it on our own products first" sat above every System1
  product, including ones that sell no subscriptions. RoadWarrior, Vinny and Joybox now sit under "We use it on our own
  subscription products first", and the other System1 products are listed apart, with no claim about Checkbox.
