# Risk and decisions

> Which items Checkbox always asks you to fix, which ones are your call, how accepting a risk works (owner only), and what reopens a decision.

Checkbox splits every item in your compliance plan into two kinds.

**Do this.** Three things are always asked for, and can never be accepted as a risk:

1. the renewal terms clearly next to the purchase button, with consent (on your page, in your Stripe Checkout settings and
   on every live Payment Link);
2. easy online cancellation (your own cancel path and your billing platform's self-serve cancel);
3. the required reminder and acknowledgment emails.

They cost next to nothing in sign-ups and help prevent disputes (Stripe recommends a clear cancellation policy that
customers agree to: [Preventing disputes](https://docs.stripe.com/disputes/prevention/best-practices)). If you or your
agent try to accept, decline or mark one of them not applicable, Checkbox says no and explains why (the API answers
`409 do_this_not_acceptable`).

The first item means your renewal terms next to the button and the sentence that clicking it agrees to them.

**Not checked by default.** Two small-state rules are not part of your plan, and Checkbox never reports them as passing:

- Vermont: bold renewal terms for plans of 1 year or longer, and a separate opt-in to the renewal for those plans
  (9 V.S.A. § 2454a);
- D.C.: separate consent for free trials that convert to paid (D.C. Code § 28A-203(c)(2)).

No item, question or accepted risk is created for them, and a site reaches done without them. They are available if
you want them: Checkbox Elements with `extras="vt-dc"`, the snippet-rendered disclosure with `?extras=vt-dc`, or
`POST /v1/checks/region` for Stripe Checkout.

**Your call.** Everything else (a Terms section, including Terms wording that contradicts online cancellation or a
refund promise, the yearly terms notice in some states, charge or price-change notices, a cancellation-confirmation email,
the New York questions…). The cancel path itself is Do this; what your Terms say about it is your call. Each one shows:

- the law, with its citation;
- the **risk if skipped** for your business: very low, low, medium or high, with a one-line reason
  ([how it is estimated](https://checkbox.site/docs/guides/risk));
- the **cost to sign-ups** of fixing it: none, small or noticeable.

You choose **Fix** or **Accept risk**.

## Accepting a risk

- Only the owner of the Checkbox organization can accept a risk, signed in to the dashboard (the site's To-do page), with
  a short reason.
- Checkbox records who accepted it, when, the reason and what it knew of your business at the time (aggregate subscriber
  counts only, never names or emails).
- The item then reads **Risk accepted**. It is never shown as passing, and the plan never says "Checks pass" while one is
  accepted: once every Do-this item is met and every Your-call item is met or accepted, the plan status is
  `risk_accepted` ("Done · risk accepted").
- You can take an acceptance back at any time ("Fix it instead").

**AI agents propose, never accept.** An agent may call `proposeRiskAcceptance` (over MCP: `call_api` with
`operation_id: "proposeRiskAcceptance"`) with a reason. That sends you a link: nothing is accepted until you open it,
signed in, and confirm with a reason in your own words (a reason that repeats the agent's word for word is recorded as
the agent's). On a Your-call item, an agent's `updateTask` with `wont_fix` or `not_applicable` is the same proposal. An
API key cannot accept a risk in any other way (`answerTask` has no such answer, and setting a finding to `accepted_risk`
is refused for API keys). In the dashboard, marking a finding "Risk accepted" needs the owner role, is refused for a
Do-this item, and is recorded like any other acceptance.

## What reopens a decision

Checkbox checks these at every plan read and in the background. When one fires, the item reopens with the reason:

- the subscribers the item's laws reach grow by at least 50% and by at least 25 since you accepted;
- your business moves up a size band (fewer than 100, 100 to 1,000, 1,000 to 10,000, more than 10,000 subscribers);
- the law Checkbox checks for that item changes;
- your 90-day dispute rate rises a quarter of a percentage point or more above what it was;
- the item comes to cover a requirement or a state you did not accept;
- Checkbox did not know your subscriber numbers when you accepted (or only had an estimate), and now reads them from
  live Stripe;
- 12 months pass.

When a decision reopens, Checkbox tells you through your notification channels, with the reason.

## In the API, MCP and CI

- Each task in the [compliance plan](https://checkbox.site/docs/guides/compliance-plan) has `kind` (`do_this` or `your_call`),
  `risk_if_skipped`, `conversion_impact` and `risk_decision` (`open`, `fixed` or `accepted`, with the reason, when, and
  `revisit_triggers`). The plan has `exposure`, `exposure_summary` and, while Your-call items are open, `owner_decisions`:
  one message to send the owner. Once every Do-this item is met, the plan's `next_action` is that one decision
  (`decide_your_call`); an agent may still fix any of the items.
- `checkbox ci`: a failing Do-this item fails the run as before; an open Your-call item is "needs review" and does not fail
  the run unless you pass `--strict`; an accepted item (read with `--online`) is listed and never fails the run.

Not legal advice: the levels are estimates, and the law stays what it is.
