# Free trials and intro offers: $1.99 for the first month, then $19.99

> What US automatic-renewal laws ask of a free trial or an introductory price such as "$1.99 for your first month, then $19.99 a month" — the price after the offer at checkout, consent to the renewal, the reminder before a long offer ends — and what Checkbox checks today.

> **Short answer**
>
> Next to the buy button, say what the customer pays during the offer, the regular price after it, how often, that the plan renews automatically until cancelled, and how to cancel. Showing only the $1.99 is not enough: California and New York want the later price explained too. Offers that last more than 31 days also need a reminder in California, 3 to 21 days before the offer ends.

*Last checked: November 8, 2026. Every rule linked below cites its source.*

An introductory price ("$1.99 for your first month") and a free trial raise the same question: will the customer know
what they pay **after** the offer? Most automatic-renewal laws treat the later price as a material term, so it belongs in
the checkout disclosure, the acknowledgment email and, for longer offers, a reminder before the offer ends.

## At checkout {#checkout}

- **The offer and the price after it.** New York requires a business with a free trial or a temporary price to
  "clearly and conspicuously explain how and when the price will change and the price or prices that will subsequently
  be charged" ([N.Y. Gen. Bus. Law § 527-a(1)(a)](https://checkbox.site/laws/new-york#signup)). California asks a free trial to explain the
  price charged after the trial ([§ 17602(a)(1)](https://checkbox.site/laws/california#signup)).
- **The renewal terms**: that it renews automatically until cancelled, how often, and how to cancel
  ([15 U.S.C. § 8403(1)](https://checkbox.site/laws/federal#signup)).
- **Consent to the renewal**, including terms offered at a promotional or discounted price for a limited time
  ([N.Y. Gen. Bus. Law § 527-a(1)(b)](https://checkbox.site/laws/new-york#signup)): an unchecked box the customer ticks, labelled with the
  renewal terms.

## What Checkbox finds on a "$1.99 first month" checkout {#example}

A common checkout line names only the offer. Here it is checked against every state at once, offline:

```bash
cat > intro.json <<'JSON'
{
  "text": "Get your first month for $1.99. Cancel anytime.",
  "price": 19.99, "interval": "month", "intro_price": 1.99, "intro_periods": 1,
  "merchant_name": "Acme", "cancel_url": "https://acme.example/account/cancel",
  "placement": { "bold": true }, "consent": { "checkbox": true }
}
JSON
checkbox check disclosure --offline --body intro.json
```

```text title="Output (abridged)"
FAIL  disclosure · all jurisdictions · rules 1.4.0 · catalog 2026.11.17.1 · offline
  ✗ signup.disclosure.autorenew_language (critical)
  ✗ signup.disclosure.price (critical)
      The recurring charge amount is not stated in the terms next to the purchase button — the checkout you sent:
      the checkout states “$1.99”, but the plan charges 19.99 USD every month (billing platform) — state the
      recurring charge subscribers will actually pay
  ✗ signup.disclosure.frequency (critical)
  ? signup.disclosure.cancellation_policy (critical)
  ✗ signup.disclosure.term_length (critical)

Suggested replacement (passes the checks) (verified by the rules engine)
  disclosure:     $1.99 for your first month, then $19.99 every month. Renews automatically until you cancel. Cancel anytime
                  online at https://acme.example/account/cancel.
  fuller version: $1.99 for your first month, then $19.99 every month. Your Acme subscription automatically renews every month
                  at $19.99 (plus applicable taxes) until you cancel. You can cancel anytime online at
                  https://acme.example/account/cancel; cancellation takes effect at the end of your current
                  billing period. To avoid the next charge, cancel before your next billing date (every
                  month).
```

"Cancel anytime" is a policy, not instructions: the check asks for **how** to cancel (a link or the steps). When the
intro price lasts more than one period, say how many ("$1.99 a month for your first 3 months"); Checkbox compares the
stated length with the plan's.

## Before the offer ends {#reminder}

- **California:** a notice 3 to 21 days before a free trial **or promotional price** lasting more than 31 days ends
  ([§ 17602(a)(8), (b)(1)](https://checkbox.site/laws/california#reminder)).
- **Connecticut** and **Illinois** have their own notices for trials and promotional periods (32 days or more, and 15
  days or more): see [Connecticut](https://checkbox.site/laws/connecticut) and [Illinois](https://checkbox.site/laws/illinois).
- Free trials have more windows, state by state: [free-trial notices](https://checkbox.site/docs/learn/free-trial-notices).

> **What Checkbox does not check yet**
>
> Checkbox's reminder checks for these notices run when the plan has a **free trial**. A paid introductory price that
> lasts more than 31 days (for example a discounted first quarter) is covered by these laws, but Checkbox does not yet
> evaluate the notice before it ends. Schedule that one yourself from the windows above.

## With Stripe {#stripe}

In Stripe, an intro price is usually a coupon (`percent_off` or `amount_off` with a duration) or a first-period price.
Give the same facts to the check (`intro_percent_off` or `intro_amount_off`, and `intro_periods`) and it writes the
disclosure from them. For Stripe Checkout itself: [Does your Stripe Checkout meet auto-renewal laws?](https://checkbox.site/docs/learn/stripe-checkout-auto-renewal-compliance)

## Related {#related}

- [Free-trial notices](https://checkbox.site/docs/learn/free-trial-notices)
- [Price increases on subscriptions](https://checkbox.site/docs/learn/subscription-price-increases)
- [Subscription compliance checklist](https://checkbox.site/docs/learn/subscription-compliance-checklist)

## Check it free with Checkbox {#free-check}

Checkbox runs these checks on your real sign-up page, emails and cancellation flow and gives you the exact wording and settings to change. Free, no credit card: [check your site](https://app.checkbox.site/sign-up).

Try one check offline first, no account needed ([the CLI](https://checkbox.site/docs/cli#offline)):

```bash
npx @checkbox-site/cli check disclosure --offline --text 'Acme Pro is $19.99 per month.' --price 19.99 --interval month --merchant-name Acme
```

Or connect your AI coding agent (Claude Code shown; [Cursor, VS Code, Codex and others](https://checkbox.site/docs/mcp)) and ask it to check your subscription flow:

```text title="MCP"
claude mcp add --transport http checkbox https://app.checkbox.site/mcp
```
