Learn: subscription auto-renewal law, answered
Plain answers about US automatic-renewal law for subscription businesses — before launch, Stripe, Shopify and Recharge, Paddle and Lemon Squeezy, cancellation, trials and intro offers, and state laws — each with citations and a last-checked date.
Plain answers to the questions subscription businesses ask about US automatic-renewal law, each with its citations and the date it was last checked. Pick a question below.
Before launch · Stripe · Shopify and Recharge · Paddle and Lemon Squeezy · Cancellation · Trials and intro offers · State laws
Before launch
What does a subscription checkout need before it goes live?
- What does a subscription business need to do to follow US auto-renewal laws? Show the renewal terms clearly next to the buy button before you take payment details, and get a separate, provable yes to the renewal.
- What are the most common auto-renewal mistakes subscription businesses make? Renewal terms that are missing or far from the buy button, no separate box to agree to the renewal, a payment receipt instead of an acknowledgment email, trials that convert without the required reminder, and cancellation that needs a call or a chat.
- What does ROSCA require for online subscriptions? ROSCA, the federal law for subscriptions sold online, requires three things before you charge a customer through an automatic renewal or free-to-paid trial.
- What do plaintiffs' lawyers look for in subscription checkouts? The same few failures come up again and again: renewal terms that are unclear or far from the buy button, cancellation that is hard to find or finish, and no separate consent to the renewal or no proof of it.
- Checkouts that pass the checks and still convert What the laws require of a subscription checkout is small — one clear line next to your own pay button that ends with the consent sentence, online cancellation and the required emails. No checkbox, no "Agree &" button.
Stripe
What do I change in Stripe?
- Does your Stripe Checkout meet auto-renewal laws? Not by default: Stripe's hosted page shows the price and interval but not that the plan renews until cancelled, how to cancel, or a box the customer must tick for the renewal.
- Stripe Checkout Make a Stripe Checkout subscription sign-up pass every applicable check — the exact Checkout Session params (one renewal line next to Stripe's button, no extra checkbox), the disclosure before the redirect, and how to verify it.
- Stripe Payment Links Add the auto-renewal disclosure (custom_text, ending with the consent sentence) to a subscription Stripe Payment Link, check its params against ROSCA and state automatic-renewal laws, and update existing links in place.
- Stripe customer portal: cancellation settings for auto-renewal laws Turn on cancellation in Stripe's Billing customer portal so subscribers can cancel online (click to cancel) as ROSCA, California and New York require — the exact billing_portal configuration, live-mode settings, the account-page link and trial reminders.
Shopify and Recharge
What can Checkbox check on a Shopify store with Recharge?
- Can Checkbox check a Shopify store that sells subscriptions through Recharge? Yes, for your pages, emails and cancellation flow: Checkbox checks the product page as your checkout, the subscription emails you BCC to it, and the cancellation flow with a test account you give it.
- Shopify Connect a Shopify store with subscriptions to Checkbox, publish the verified renewal-terms block, and monitor the storefront and subscription emails.
- Recharge Connect a Recharge store so Checkbox reads plans and subscription events, and check Recharge's notification emails and cancellation flow.
Paddle and Lemon Squeezy
Selling through a merchant of record?
- Do auto-renewal laws matter if Paddle or Lemon Squeezy is my merchant of record? They still shape the parts you control.
- Paddle Connect Paddle Billing with a read-only API key so Checkbox reads your prices, trials and subscription events, and see what Paddle does for you as merchant of record.
Cancellation
How must customers be able to cancel?
- How must an online cancellation flow work under California and New York law? A customer who signed up online must be able to cancel online, immediately, and at least as easily as they signed up.
- Does the FTC click-to-cancel rule apply to my subscription business? No: the FTC's 2024 click-to-cancel rule was vacated in full by the Eighth Circuit on July 8, 2025, before its main compliance date, and no replacement rule has been adopted.
- Online cancellation What "cancel online" requires, how Checkbox tests your cancellation flow, and the hosted cancellation page you can use instead of building one.
Trials and intro offers
What do free trials, renewals, intro prices and price increases require?
- Do I have to send a reminder before a free trial ends? In many states, yes: California and New York require one 3 to 21 days before a trial longer than a month converts, and Utah requires one for a trial of any length, at least 3 days before.
- Do I have to send a renewal reminder email before a subscription renews? For yearly and other long plans, usually yes: California and New York require a reminder 15 to 45 days before a plan with an initial term of a year or more renews, and many other states ask for 30 to 60 days.
- What must a checkout say about a free trial or an intro price like $1.99 for the first month? Next to the buy button, say what the customer pays during the offer, the regular price after it, how often, that the plan renews automatically until cancelled, and how to cancel.
- How do I raise the price of an existing subscription? Send a notice before the change takes effect: California asks for it 7 to 30 days before, and New York at least 5 business days and no more than 30 days before.
State laws
Which state laws apply, and what do they add?
- Which US states have automatic-renewal laws, and what do they require? The states, DC and New York City listed below have automatic-renewal laws in Checkbox's catalog; they apply based on where the customer is, so a business selling online sells into all of them.
- What does California's Automatic Renewal Law require? California requires the renewal terms clearly and conspicuously next to the consent request, express consent to the renewal itself, and an acknowledgment the customer can keep.
- What does New York's automatic renewal law require since November 2025? New York's rewritten law requires the terms, including the deadline to act, before consent or billing details, and the subscriber's consent or a refund right for price increases.
Check your own site, free
These guides explain the rules; Checkbox checks your real sign-up page, emails and cancellation flow against them and gives you the exact fix. Free, no credit card: check your site. The rules themselves are on the law pages and in the open dataset.