Selling through Paddle or Lemon Squeezy: what auto-renewal rules still touch
When a merchant of record such as Paddle or Lemon Squeezy takes the payment, which parts of a subscription flow are still yours, what the merchant of record already does, and what Checkbox checks and does on each platform today.
Last checked: November 9, 2026. Every rule linked below cites its source.
A merchant of record (MoR) such as Paddle or Lemon Squeezy sells your product on your behalf: it runs the checkout, takes the payment, handles sales tax and is the name on the receipt. That moves a lot of work off your plate. It does not move your pricing page, the terms you write or your account page.
Who the laws are written about
- ROSCA, the federal law, makes it unlawful for "any person to charge or attempt to charge any consumer" through an online negative option feature without clear disclosure, express informed consent and a simple way to stop the charges (15 U.S.C. § 8403).
- California addresses "any business that makes an automatic renewal offer or continuous service offer to a consumer" in the state (Cal. Bus. & Prof. Code § 17602(a)). Many other state laws are written the same way.
With a merchant of record, the company that makes the offer (you, on your pricing page) and the company that charges (the merchant of record) can be two different companies. Checkbox does not decide which of you a law holds responsible; that is a question for your lawyer. What Checkbox can do is check what your subscribers actually see.
What is still yours
- The offer on your page. The price, the renewal terms and the button that opens the merchant of record's checkout. Put the full renewal terms and a required, unchecked consent checkbox directly above that button.
- Your own emails. Welcome emails, renewal reminders and price-change notices you send yourself.
- The way to cancel. A clear "Cancel subscription" link from your account page to wherever cancelling happens.
- Your Terms. "No cancellations" or "cancel by email only" in your Terms contradicts the online-cancellation rules even when the merchant of record's portal lets people cancel.
What the merchant of record already does
Paddle's own documentation says it includes a customer portal where subscribers can cancel, emails a receipt for every payment, and emails a trial-ending reminder for trials that took a card (not for cardless trials). It describes no renewal reminder, yearly reminder, price-change notice or cancellation-confirmation email. The Paddle guide quotes and links each source.
For Lemon Squeezy, check its own documentation for the emails and customer portal it provides: Checkbox does not read Lemon Squeezy's settings, so it judges those parts only on what it sees (your pages and the emails you forward).
What Checkbox does on each platform today
| Paddle | Lemon Squeezy | |
|---|---|---|
| Your pricing page: renewal terms and consent | Checked in a real browser | Checked in a real browser |
| Emails (yours, and theirs you forward or BCC) | Checked | Checked |
| Cancellation flow | Checked by clicking through from your account page; Paddle's portal is Not checked yet until Checkbox has evidence | Checked by clicking through from your account page, when Checkbox can reach it |
| Billing connection (prices, trials, subscription events) | Yes, with a read-only Paddle Billing API key and webhook | Not yet |
| Notices (required reminders sent for you) | Yes, from Paddle's subscription events | Not yet |
| Test subscriptions | Yes: a generic test run signs up through your checkout with a 100%-off test coupon or a test account and cancels online | Yes: the same generic test run |
| Time travel through reminder windows, and the hosted cancellation page | No (Stripe only) | No (Stripe only) |
Checkbox never treats something it cannot read as passing: it shows Not checked yet until it has evidence. Setup for Paddle is in the Paddle guide.
Check it free with Checkbox
Checkbox runs these checks on your real sign-up page, emails and cancellation flow and gives you the exact wording and settings to change. Free, no credit card: check your site.
Try one check offline first, no account needed (the CLI):
npx @checkbox-site/cli check disclosure --offline --text 'Acme Pro is $19.99 per month.' --price 19.99 --interval month --merchant-name AcmeOr connect your AI coding agent (Claude Code shown; Cursor, VS Code, Codex and others) and ask it to check your subscription flow:
claude mcp add --transport http checkbox https://app.checkbox.site/mcpCheckbox is compliance software, not a law firm; nothing in these docs is legal advice (details). You remain solely responsible for your subscription program, and Checkbox takes on no legal liability for it (Terms). Checkbox is a System1 company; Trust center · Status. For AI agents: every page is available as Markdown at the same URL plus .md; the index is /llms.txt.