Common auto-renewal mistakes, and what they can cost
The automatic-renewal mistakes subscription businesses make most often — terms hidden from the buy button, no consent to the renewal, a receipt instead of an acknowledgment, missed trial reminders, hard cancellation — with the Checkbox check for each and the remedies the statutes name.
Last checked: November 8, 2026. Every rule linked below cites its source.
These are the gaps the public record shows plaintiffs and regulators pursue again and again (what plaintiffs look for). Each has a check, so you can find it on your own site before someone else does.
1. The renewal terms are not next to the buy button
The price is shown, but not that the plan renews automatically until cancelled, or how to cancel; or the terms sit in the Terms of Service, a footer or small grey text. Federal law wants all material terms disclosed clearly and conspicuously before billing information is taken (15 U.S.C. § 8403(1)).
Checks: signup.disclosure.autorenew_language, signup.disclosure.cancellation_policy, signup.disclosure.proximity, signup.disclosure.conspicuous.
2. No separate "yes" to the renewal
A pre-ticked box, or consent folded into "I agree to the Terms". California requires express affirmative consent to the renewal terms themselves (§ 17602(a)(4)) and keeping proof of it for at least three years, or one year after the contract ends if longer (§ 17602(a)(6)).
Checks: signup.consent.affirmative, signup.consent.not_prechecked.
3. A receipt instead of an acknowledgment
The payment receipt from your billing platform does not repeat the renewal terms or say how to cancel. California requires an acknowledgment the customer can keep, with the terms, the cancellation policy and how to cancel (§ 17602(a)(3)).
Checks: confirmation.email.sent, confirmation.email.terms, confirmation.email.cancellation_instructions.
4. A trial converts without the reminder
No reminder, or one sent outside the window: Stripe's optional reminder goes out 7 days before a trial ends, which misses DC's 15 to 30 days, for example. Windows by state: free-trial notices.
Checks: reminder.trial_ending, and reminder.annual_renewal for yearly plans.
5. Cancellation needs a call, a chat or an obstacle course
Customers who signed up online must be able to cancel online; a save offer may not block the way (§ 17602(d), (e); N.Y. Gen. Bus. Law § 527-a(1)(d), (e)).
Checks: cancel.online_available, cancel.mechanism_findable, cancel.flow_friction, cancel.confirmation.
6. Price changes without notice
Raising the price of an existing subscription without the notice the states require, or without New York's consent or refund right. See price increases.
Check: reminder.price_change.
What the statutes say it can cost
From Checkbox's catalog, each with its citation (full rows on each law page under "Who can sue, and remedies"):
| Law | Remedies the statute names |
|---|---|
| Federal (ROSCA) | Civil penalties up to $53,088 per violation in FTC actions (15 U.S.C. § 45(m)(1)(A), as adjusted by 16 C.F.R. § 1.98), and consumer redress (15 U.S.C. § 8404(b)). No private suit. Federal |
| California | Goods or services provided without the required consent are an unconditional gift (Bus. & Prof. Code § 17603). Private claims go through the UCL, FAL and CLRA: injunction and restitution (§§ 17203, 17535), and under the CLRA actual and punitive damages and attorney's fees (Civ. Code § 1780(a), (e)). Up to $2,500 per violation in public actions (§§ 17206(a), 17536(a)). California |
| New York | Attorney General actions: up to $100 per violation ($500 for multiple violations from one act), or $500 and $1,000 if knowing (Gen. Bus. Law § 527-a(3)). New York |
| District of Columbia | Treble damages or $1,500 per violation, whichever is greater, plus punitive damages and attorney's fees (D.C. Code § 28-3905(k)(2)). DC |
| Debit card or ACH billing (EFTA) | Actual damages plus $100 to $1,000 in an individual action, and attorney's fees (15 U.S.C. § 1693m(a)). Federal |
Settlements can be larger than these figures; the law pages link the agency press releases Checkbox cites.
Related
- Subscription compliance checklist
- What plaintiffs' lawyers look for
- Does your Stripe Checkout meet auto-renewal laws?
Check it free with Checkbox
Checkbox runs these checks on your real sign-up page, emails and cancellation flow and gives you the exact wording and settings to change. Free, no credit card: check your site.
Try one check offline first, no account needed (the CLI):
npx @checkbox-site/cli check disclosure --offline --text 'Acme Pro is $19.99 per month.' --price 19.99 --interval month --merchant-name AcmeOr connect your AI coding agent (Claude Code shown; Cursor, VS Code, Codex and others) and ask it to check your subscription flow:
claude mcp add --transport http checkbox https://app.checkbox.site/mcpCheckbox is compliance software, not a law firm; nothing in these docs is legal advice (details). You remain solely responsible for your subscription program, and Checkbox takes on no legal liability for it (Terms). Checkbox is a System1 company; Trust center · Status. For AI agents: every page is available as Markdown at the same URL plus .md; the index is /llms.txt.