Does the FTC click-to-cancel rule apply? Status after the July 2025 vacatur
Where the FTC's click-to-cancel rule (the 2024 Negative Option Rule amendments) stands after the Eighth Circuit vacated it on July 8, 2025, what still applies to online subscriptions (ROSCA and the state click-to-cancel laws in California, New York and others), and how to build a cancellation flow that meets them.
Last checked: November 13, 2026. Every rule linked below cites its source.
"Click to cancel" is still the rule for most online subscriptions in the United States, just not because of the FTC rule that made the phrase famous. This page sets out what happened to that rule, what applies instead, and what to build. Every statement below is from Checkbox's legal catalog, with its citation.
What happened to the FTC rule
FTC Negative Option Rule ("Use of Prenotification Negative Option Plans") — 16 C.F.R. Part 425. Effective 2026-02-12. Status: not cataloged. Source: https://www.federalregister.gov/documents/2026/02/12/2026-02866/revision-of-the-negative-option-rule-withdrawal-of-the-cars-rule-removal-of-the-non-compete-rule-to
NOT CATALOGED. The 2024 click-to-cancel amendments (89 FR 90476) were vacated by the Eighth Circuit on July 8, 2025 (Custom Commc'ns, Inc. v. FTC, 142 F.4th 1060). The FTC restored the 1973 prenotification-plan rule effective Feb. 12, 2026 (91 FR 6507); it applies only to prenotification negative option plans (periodic announcements of selections), not ordinary subscriptions. An ANPRM was published Mar. 13, 2026 (91 FR 12318; comments closed Apr. 13, 2026); no proposed or final rule as of 2026-10-29. Re-check the Federal Register before relying on this.
- Amendment: 89 FR 90476 (Nov. 15, 2024) — "Rule Concerning Recurring Subscriptions and Other Negative Option Programs", effective 2025-01-14: Click-to-cancel amendments. The rule took effect Jan. 14, 2025, but most provisions had a compliance date of July 14, 2025; the Eighth Circuit vacated the whole rule on July 8, 2025, before that compliance date. None of it is enforceable.
- Amendment: 91 FR 6507 (Feb. 12, 2026), effective 2026-02-12: Conforming final rule recodifying the pre-2024 prenotification rule after the vacatur.
- Amendment: 91 FR 12318 (Mar. 13, 2026), RIN 3084-AB54, effective 2026-03-13: Advance notice of proposed rulemaking (no rule text; no legal effect).
In order:
- November 15, 2024: the FTC published amendments to its Negative Option Rule ("Rule Concerning Recurring Subscriptions and Other Negative Option Programs", 89 FR 90476), including a requirement that cancelling be at least as easy as signing up. Most provisions had a compliance date of July 14, 2025.
- July 8, 2025: the Eighth Circuit vacated the whole rule, before that compliance date: Custom Commc'ns, Inc. v. FTC, 142 F.4th 1060 (8th Cir. 2025). None of it is enforceable.
- February 12, 2026: the FTC restored the older rule (91 FR 6507). It covers only prenotification plans (periodic announcements of "selections", book-of-the-month style), not ordinary automatic-renewal subscriptions.
- March 13, 2026: the FTC published an advance notice of proposed rulemaking (91 FR 12318; comments closed April 13, 2026). As of the catalog's last check, no proposed or final rule has been published.
Checkbox re-checks the Federal Register as part of its law updates and will add requirements if a new federal rule is adopted.
What applies instead
Federal law: ROSCA. The Restore Online Shoppers' Confidence Act requires a "simple mechanism" for a consumer to stop recurring charges, along with the up-front disclosure and express consent (15 U.S.C. § 8403). ROSCA does not itself say "as easy as sign-up", but the FTC argues in ROSCA cases that a multi-step, hard-to-find or retention-heavy online flow is not simple (for example its ROSCA case over Amazon Prime cancellation, W.D. Wash., settled September 2025). Details: ROSCA explained.
State laws. The states apply based on where the customer is, so a business selling online sells into all of them:
| Rule | Where | Citation |
|---|---|---|
| Customers who signed up online can cancel online, with a prominent "click to cancel" link or button | California | Cal. Bus. & Prof. Code § 17602(d) |
| Save offers only with a continuously shown "click to cancel" option | California | § 17602(e) |
| Cancellation as easy as sign-up, in the same medium; no obstruction or delay | New York | N.Y. Gen. Bus. Law § 527-a(1)(d), (e) |
| Same, plus a refund of everything charged after a first failed attempt to cancel | New York City | 6 RCNY § 5-110.1, § 5-110.2 |
| Retention offers only if the customer opts in (Minnesota); no live agent required to cancel (Virginia, Maryland) | Minnesota, Virginia, Maryland | every state |
So the practical answer has not changed since 2024: if customers sign up online, let them cancel online, quickly, from their account page, without a call or a chat.
What to build
- A Cancel subscription link one click from the account page (and linked from the checkout disclosure, the acknowledgment email and every reminder).
- One confirmation screen. A save offer may sit beside the cancel button, never in front of it.
- An on-screen confirmation with the end date, and the same in an email.
With Stripe Billing, the quickest way is the customer portal with cancellation turned on:
{
"features": {
"subscription_cancel": { "enabled": true, "mode": "at_period_end" }
}
}Screens, server code and the cancellation email: online cancellation flow. Portal settings: Stripe customer portal.
Check a cancellation confirmation email
checkbox check email --kind cancellation_confirmation --subject "Your Acme subscription has been canceled" \
--text "Your Acme subscription has been canceled. You will not be charged again, and you keep access until March 1, 2027. Questions? Contact us at support@acme.example." \
--merchant-name Acme --price 19.99 --interval month --offlineCheckbox also opens your real account page and follows the cancel path in a Stripe test subscription, so the cancel.* checks are observed rather than assumed: test runs.
Check it free with Checkbox
Checkbox runs these checks on your real sign-up page, emails and cancellation flow and gives you the exact wording and settings to change. Free, no credit card: check your site.
Try one check offline first, no account needed (the CLI):
npx @checkbox-site/cli check disclosure --offline --text 'Acme Pro is $19.99 per month.' --price 19.99 --interval month --merchant-name AcmeOr connect your AI coding agent (Claude Code shown; Cursor, VS Code, Codex and others) and ask it to check your subscription flow:
claude mcp add --transport http checkbox https://app.checkbox.site/mcpCheckbox is compliance software, not a law firm; nothing in these docs is legal advice (details). You remain solely responsible for your subscription program, and Checkbox takes on no legal liability for it (Terms). Checkbox is a System1 company; Trust center · Status. For AI agents: every page is available as Markdown at the same URL plus .md; the index is /llms.txt.