Free trials and intro offers: $1.99 for the first month, then $19.99
What US automatic-renewal laws ask of a free trial or an introductory price such as "$1.99 for your first month, then $19.99 a month" — the price after the offer at checkout, consent to the renewal, the reminder before a long offer ends — and what Checkbox checks today.
Last checked: November 8, 2026. Every rule linked below cites its source.
An introductory price ("$1.99 for your first month") and a free trial raise the same question: will the customer know what they pay after the offer? Most automatic-renewal laws treat the later price as a material term, so it belongs in the checkout disclosure, the acknowledgment email and, for longer offers, a reminder before the offer ends.
At checkout
- The offer and the price after it. New York requires a business with a free trial or a temporary price to "clearly and conspicuously explain how and when the price will change and the price or prices that will subsequently be charged" (N.Y. Gen. Bus. Law § 527-a(1)(a)). California asks a free trial to explain the price charged after the trial (§ 17602(a)(1)).
- The renewal terms: that it renews automatically until cancelled, how often, and how to cancel (15 U.S.C. § 8403(1)).
- Consent to the renewal, including terms offered at a promotional or discounted price for a limited time (N.Y. Gen. Bus. Law § 527-a(1)(b)): an unchecked box the customer ticks, labelled with the renewal terms.
What Checkbox finds on a "$1.99 first month" checkout
A common checkout line names only the offer. Here it is checked against every state at once, offline:
cat > intro.json <<'JSON'
{
"text": "Get your first month for $1.99. Cancel anytime.",
"price": 19.99, "interval": "month", "intro_price": 1.99, "intro_periods": 1,
"merchant_name": "Acme", "cancel_url": "https://acme.example/account/cancel",
"placement": { "bold": true }, "consent": { "checkbox": true }
}
JSON
checkbox check disclosure --offline --body intro.jsonFAIL disclosure · all jurisdictions · rules 1.4.0 · catalog 2026.11.17.1 · offline
✗ signup.disclosure.autorenew_language (critical)
✗ signup.disclosure.price (critical)
The recurring charge amount is not stated in the terms next to the purchase button — the checkout you sent:
the checkout states “$1.99”, but the plan charges 19.99 USD every month (billing platform) — state the
recurring charge subscribers will actually pay
✗ signup.disclosure.frequency (critical)
? signup.disclosure.cancellation_policy (critical)
✗ signup.disclosure.term_length (critical)
Suggested replacement (passes the checks) (verified by the rules engine)
disclosure: $1.99 for your first month, then $19.99 every month. Renews automatically until you cancel. Cancel anytime
online at https://acme.example/account/cancel.
fuller version: $1.99 for your first month, then $19.99 every month. Your Acme subscription automatically renews every month
at $19.99 (plus applicable taxes) until you cancel. You can cancel anytime online at
https://acme.example/account/cancel; cancellation takes effect at the end of your current
billing period. To avoid the next charge, cancel before your next billing date (every
month)."Cancel anytime" is a policy, not instructions: the check asks for how to cancel (a link or the steps). When the intro price lasts more than one period, say how many ("$1.99 a month for your first 3 months"); Checkbox compares the stated length with the plan's.
Before the offer ends
- California: a notice 3 to 21 days before a free trial or promotional price lasting more than 31 days ends (§ 17602(a)(8), (b)(1)).
- Connecticut and Illinois have their own notices for trials and promotional periods (32 days or more, and 15 days or more): see Connecticut and Illinois.
- Free trials have more windows, state by state: free-trial notices.
With Stripe
In Stripe, an intro price is usually a coupon (percent_off or amount_off with a duration) or a first-period price. Give the same facts to the check (intro_percent_off or intro_amount_off, and intro_periods) and it writes the disclosure from them. For Stripe Checkout itself: Does your Stripe Checkout meet auto-renewal laws?
Related
Check it free with Checkbox
Checkbox runs these checks on your real sign-up page, emails and cancellation flow and gives you the exact wording and settings to change. Free, no credit card: check your site.
Try one check offline first, no account needed (the CLI):
npx @checkbox-site/cli check disclosure --offline --text 'Acme Pro is $19.99 per month.' --price 19.99 --interval month --merchant-name AcmeOr connect your AI coding agent (Claude Code shown; Cursor, VS Code, Codex and others) and ask it to check your subscription flow:
claude mcp add --transport http checkbox https://app.checkbox.site/mcpCheckbox is compliance software, not a law firm; nothing in these docs is legal advice (details). You remain solely responsible for your subscription program, and Checkbox takes on no legal liability for it (Terms). Checkbox is a System1 company; Trust center · Status. For AI agents: every page is available as Markdown at the same URL plus .md; the index is /llms.txt.