Checkbox Docs

For counsel

One page for a lawyer reviewing a client's use of Checkbox — what it checks, what it does not, how a verdict is reached, how to verify the evidence, and what Checkbox does not promise.

Checkbox runs automated checks of a business's subscription sign-up, emails and cancellation against U.S. automatic-renewal laws. This page is for the lawyer reviewing that use. It is not legal advice, it does not guarantee compliance, and no lawyer has reviewed the rules; the legal disclaimer and the Terms control.

What is covered

  • Laws: federal law (ROSCA and Regulation E), 27 states, DC and New York City. Each law page lists the rules, their citations and links to the official text; the open dataset has every rule as JSON or CSV.
  • What is checked: the checkout disclosure and consent, the confirmation and notice emails, and cancellation (settings in the billing platform, and test cancellations in Stripe test mode).
  • How it is seen: a real browser on the rendered pages, the billing platform's API, emails received at a BCC address, and, in a code repository, the checkout parameters in the source.

What is not checked

  • Pages behind a login, unless the site installs the in-page snippet (those results are marked as reported by it).
  • Cancellation by phone or chat, and emails sent where Checkbox cannot receive them.
  • Facts a machine cannot see, such as how a New York subscriber asked to get notices. These are asked of a person and recorded as their answer, not as an observation.
  • Laws outside the catalog, and general consumer-protection claims (UCL, FAL, CLRA, FTC Act § 5) beyond the automatic-renewal rules. Some billing platforms expose fewer settings; limits lists them.
  • Not checked by default: Vermont: bold renewal terms for plans of 1 year or longer, and a separate opt-in to the renewal for those plans (9 V.S.A. § 2454a(a)(1)-(2)); D.C.: separate consent for free trials that convert to paid (D.C. Code § 28A-203(c)(2)). These are never reported as passing; a merchant can add them (Checkbox Elements extras="vt-dc").

How a verdict is reached

Each check applies a cited rule to what was observed. Pass means it was observed and met the rule; a check never passes for lack of evidence. Fail says what was seen and the fix. Needs review means the evidence is incomplete, or the rule calls for judgment (for example "clear and conspicuous"), and a person decides. One exception, so the label matches what the merchant can change: on a Stripe-hosted page (Checkout, Payment Links), where Stripe sets the size and colour of the custom text and the merchant cannot restyle it, the clear-and-conspicuous measurement (size, weight, contrast against the surrounding text) is reported as Checks pass with a note: the note gives the measurement and what the merchant can change instead, and whether that is conspicuous enough stays a call for the merchant or counsel. Hidden text still fails. The sample report (checkbox.site/sample-report) shows one. Every result carries the rules and catalog versions and a catalog hash, so it can be reproduced. Details: checks and verdicts.

Evidence you can verify yourself

This is the record a client can produce in a chargeback, a demand letter or a regulator's inquiry: the terms each subscriber saw next to the button and the consent they gave, every required notice and when it went out, and what each check observed. What a passing check means lists what is checked mechanically and what is left to judgment.

What Checkbox observed (screenshots, page HTML, emails, settings, consent records) is stored hash-chained and signed (evidence). A consent receipt downloads as a bundle with a standalone verify.mjs (Node.js, no dependencies) that checks every hash and signature against Checkbox's published keys (receipts).

Accuracy and corrections

The rules are written by the Checkbox team from the text of each law; how they are kept accurate describes the sources and reviews. Errors are fixed and listed with dates in the corrections log. To report one, email support@checkbox.site.

Checkbox is compliance software, not a law firm; nothing in these docs is legal advice (details). You remain solely responsible for your subscription program, and Checkbox takes on no legal liability for it (Terms). Checkbox is a System1 company; Trust center · Status. For AI agents: every page is available as Markdown at the same URL plus .md; the index is /llms.txt.